
The Anthropic Principle
Lest I forget once I get to juggling with numbers again, I must point out two books by Hugh Ross on this topic: Why the Universe is the Way it is (Baker, 2008) and The Improbable Planet ( Baker, 2016).
Let us remain with Stuart Kauffman for another moment, in the email interview mentioned on the previous page, George Horgan, writing for Scientific American, asked Kauffman, "Care to comment on the state of theoretical physics?" Kauffman immediately made it clear that he was not a physicist, but then declared his preference.
| Not a physicist. But that does not stop one from worrying. 10500 string theories and a cosmic landscape? Can't write down the theory? Not testable? Pretty sad, and presumes pre-existing background space or spacetime. Don't like. Don't like anthropic principle. We can consider evolution of laws and constants to create a more complex universe that wins, Darwin all the way down, testable by finding constants evolved. (Sci Am) |
This answer is, of course, consistent with his overall theory that there are no permanent laws governing the development of life and its evolution. As we mentioned, the only law that he depends on is his own law that says that life is not determined by immutable scientific laws. As we see in this quotation, he was appalled at the various ideas that had become popular. Obviously, there are not 5 googols of string theories, but Kauffman's critique focuses on two points, namely that ...
1. ... the complex theories that various physicists advance nowadays cannot be confirmed experimentally, and that ...
2. ... they presume universal uniformity, viz. the laws governing what happened 3.8 billion years ago have not changed. Specifically, the mathematical constants that applied back then are supposed to be the same ones we have learned nowadays.
As we saw on the previous page, Kauffman used neither classical nor quantum concepts alone. The development of life is unpredictable and cannot be chained by our neat mathematical systems.
As a relatively easy example, we know that the gravitational constant in classical physics (without specifying units) is 6.6743 × 10-11. But Kauffman won't let us assume that this has alwllaays been the case. The "laws" that we single out to describe changes in the universe are also subject to change. In his view, most scientists make assumptions that are inconsistent with their claims. The Big Bang theory generally entails that there was no universe prior to its explosion, and, thus, no space, time, or physical laws. The laws in question emerged with the universe and, according to Kauffman, there is no good reason to think that they have not changed in the process.
This opinion, specifically the possibility of a variance in the gravitational constant over the development of the universe had already been proposed by Paul Dirac (1902-1984), one of the leading scholars among physicists in the twentieth century, sometimes even ranked alongside Einstein. He had found an unexpected anomaly in Einstein's theory of general relativity, but the need for that adjustment faded away with a better measurement of the shape of the sun, which is not a perfect circle. Dirac predicted the existence of anti-matter, which was subsequently confirmed by Antonino Zichichi (see part 15) in 1965.
In Kauffman's view, if we try to find a fundamental pattern in the course of evolution, we are reading something into the data that simply isn't there. In particular, he nixes the idea that there was a goal underlying the process. Considered worse yet, he rejects the idea that in some mysterious way, biological evolution has reached its goal with the coming of homo sapiens, the pinnacle of life forms. This idea that he rejects is the "anthropic principle." Nonetheless, all disclaimers aside, his entire analysis can only be understood as directional, given that molecules supposedly actualize their potentials at the cost of increasing their expenditure of energy, and that they violate their own equilibrium. Why would they do that if they were not aiming is some direction? Along with the trite declaration that "nature abhors a vacuum," in Kauffman's world we would also have to state that "nature does not prefer an equilibrium." The second statement can only be reasonable if either 1) the factors that produce equilibrium are not available, or 2) there are some other factors that force a simple state to become more complex. Otherwise, as demonstrated over a long time now, the operations within the cosmos appear always to be happiest at home in an equilibrial state.
According to many evolution scientists, theories of the origin of life are not synonymous with the theory of evolution. Thus, we are allegedly making a category mistake by addressing both simultaneously. Strictly speaking, those two ideas are different aspects of the more fundamental theory of naturalist evolution. So, this accusation would be effective if it were not for the fact that evolutionists themselves violate this principle as well. Note that Kauffman invokes Darwin for his cosmology, thereby presumably applying natural selection to the constituant parts of the universe, which make little sense. However, he insists that his view is defensible and subject to verification if we only let go of the bad habbit of thinking that our scientific laws have not changed.
So, how can you test that belief? What it comes down to is that there is a conceptual connection between the two, and that link is naturalism, the notion that neither the universe nor the first emergence of life needed God to put Nature's creativity into first gear.
As we said in connection with Darwin's (possibly insincere) concession that God created the first species, it makes no sense to dismiss God from that point on. Either you agree that we live in a theistic world or you don't. It makes no sense to bring in God, the omniscient and omnipotent being as understood in the proper context, just to get the machine rolling and then to put him aside immediately thereafter. That "god-thing" would not be God; perhaps we could call it the demiurge, as invented by Plato in his dialogue Timaeus, which is not divine but the force that installed Plato's Ideal Forms into the physical universe.
But, needless to say, most evolutionary scholars are no more interested in a cosmic Artisan than in a Creator. They seem to agree with this point, i.e., that you can't use God as a tool to be hung up in the shed as soon as you decide that you don't need him anymore. So, the two areas of interest, the origin of life and the subsequent development of life are linked, as is Cin their publications despite protestations when a non-evolutionist points out their inconsistency as they, in return, chastise non-evolutionists.
Barrow and the Constants of Nature
Now, then, the anthropic principle, if correct, could become a serious hurdle on the way towards a non-theistic, non-directed understanding of origins and evolution. The arrangement of the evolutionary changes over the eons seems to manifest a deliberate order, culminating in the evolution of human beings.
In his book The Constants of Nature [(New York: Pantheon, 2002),15] John D. Barrow tells us about James Clerk Maxwell who sought a basis for stability in the universe. He found it in the identity of atoms in a given element. E.g., all the iron atoms in an iron rod are the same. Quoting Barrow,
| Maxwell pointed to the molecules of Nature as entities that were not subject to selection, adaptation, or mutation. |
It does seem pretty obvious that natural selection or adaptations to changes in the environment cannot be applied to the chaos of molecules dissolved within the "primordial broth." What we are supposed to see here is the combination of certain elements that will form further elements, given the right condition of the environment as well as the atoms involved. Specifically, what we are looking for is a way to generate carbon, which, as we said is the chemical sine qua non for life in the universe as we know it (leaving aside the rampant imaginations of other universes that we don't know). We can stipulate the necessary heat in the period of star formation; carbon compounds were the ashes of the cosmic fires.

Fred Hoyle and the Carbon Factory
Fred Hoyle was an influential cosmologist who has always felt free to ignore an apparent consensus in favor what he saw as the truth. He was one of three prominent defenders of the "steady state theory" of the universe, along with Hermann Bondi and Thomas Gold. This theory was admittedly based on the philosophical assumption that the universe has always been and always will be configured in the same way as we see it now. There is neither beginning nor end. The obvious question came up as to how that can be if the universe may be expanding. The answer was that the density of the universe is kept the same because there is a continual production of protons, supplied by the cosmos itself. For a short time a number of cosmologists accepted the theory, but it was not going to last. When the microwave background of the universe was detected and it became obvious that the farther we looked back in time, as recognized by distance away from us, the denser it was, the competing idea that there was a starting point a finite time ago linked to a possible end sometime in the distant future claimed the day.
Fred Hoyle did not renounce the steady state theory and held on to it in modified form. His new model allowed for occasional moments of growth or mini-expansions. When interviewed about the theory that had now become popular, he gave it the witty name the "Big Bang" theory. Paradoxically this initially satirical reference has become the term of art, the common name for the event.
Hoyle contributed immensely to our understanding of the generation of carbon in the stars, which "Big Bang" scholars then applied to the earliest formations of stellar system. Carbon is one of the essential elements that constitute living organisms, and since we know that we are alive, there must have been a way for it to become an early product of the Big Bang. I will try to describe the process, which once again will involve numbers, but try to keep away items that could create a puzzle maze.
Even though we are going to refer to elements, we are are actually only focusing on the nuclei. In the standard model, electrons came into play much later as the universe grew a little older.
Very importantly, this chemical action is not just presented as something that happened a long time ago; it's what's happening all over the universe at this very moment. Every time you see the sun and other stars, you are looking at the conversion of hydrogen to helium and the vast amount of energy that is released by this fusion (which is also the underlying chemistry of the hydrogen bomb). If you're out "catching some rays" and are getting a sunburned in the process, you have experienced the energy left over from the Big Bang.
So, following Hoyle's thesis, we start with single protons, that is to say the nuclei of hydrogen atoms, H+. If two of them collide, we get an element with 2 protons, and that is helium.
But that's easier said than done. Think about it: Both protons have a positive charge, and, as we all know from magnets, similar charges repel each other. The only way to overcome this barrier is by the extreme heat of the explosion of these events which is still active within stars, and the protons remain together due to the "strong force" which holds a nucleus together with other particles called gluons (a term derived from "glue-on.")
Hydrogen is the only element without neutrons. Helium, on the other hand, has 2 protons and 2 neutrons as its nucleus. Thus, if helium is the fusion of two protons, where did the neutrons come from? There is an answer, and it's a five step transformation called the proton-proton chain, whose details go beyond my reflections here. These helium nuclei are called "α-radiation" or "α-particles."
When two helium atoms combine under these radical conditions, the number of protons is doubled. Thus, we get beryllium, an element with four protons.
Now things get exciting. If the beryllium meets up with another α/helium nucleus, they could merge and become a carbon molecule. Carbon is more stable than beryllium. Then again, the newly created carbon could handle the addition of yet another helium nucleus, and turn into oxygen, though that is an extremely rare event, as I will clarify below. Here is a basic outline of this adventure.
1H +1H => 2He
2He + 2He => 4Be [4Be +4Be => 8O is too unstable to occur.]
4Be + 2He => 6C [6C + 2He => 8O is rare because their energy levels do not match.]
Needless to say, there is a cost involved; the process of creating helium gives up a lot of light and heat. Atomic nuclei have measurable amounts of energy, given in terms of MeV, a "million electron volts." That sounds like a large number until we realize that the energy of one electron volt represents equals 1.602 x 10-19 joules (units of energy). In other words, we would need to put 19 zeroes before the 1 after the decimal point. So, a million of them would gives us 1.602 x 10-12 joules called "ergs," a number with fewer digits, but still tiny. Be that as it may, it is of the utmost import for the fusion of atoms, viz, producing a new element.
Fred Hoyle used these numbers to demonstrate the origin of atoms or, more precisely, atomic nuclei. If he was to have any hope of demonstrating the plausibility of his of ideas, they needed to be demonstrated with lab-tested numbers, not just as computations made by pencil on paper. His calculations were based on the the supposition of the "resonance of atomic nuclei." "Resonance" here refers to the state in which the energy of two joining nuclei is extremely close to the energy level of the resulting element. Even what looks like a tiny difference to us may be too extensive for the protons to link up. Hoyle's goal was to find the mechanism for carbon to be produced because carbon is essential for all life forms.
Hoyle's calculations indicated that the combination of beryllium and a third alpha particle (helium) would need a unique relatively stable number for carbon to be in resonance with beryllium. Unfortunately, the number that Hoyle came up with was not known to exist: 7.65 MeV. He was able to enlist a team of colleagues at Cal Tech consisting of William A. Fowler, Margaret Burbridge, and her husband, Geoffrey, who set up instruments to search for this number--and they found it. Together they published a paper titled "Synthesis of Elements in the Stars," which was not only a formal presentation of Hoyle's methods and conclusions, it validated that there was, indeed, an energy state of 7.65 MeV for Carbon, and that it was quite stable. The paper had a significant impact, and scientists refer to it by the initial letters of the authors' names, the "B2FH" paper.
But, as alluded to above, we're still not out of the chemical woods. If the result of combining two helium nucleons, giving us berylium, and if the berylium can then pick up a third α/helium particle to yield carbon with 3 α-particles, why can't the process go on with another α/helium tandem joining the carbon combination, thereby forming oxygen with 8 protons? If that had been possible, it would have been a serious problem because oxygen would have burned up the new-born carbon, thereby closing the door to the emergence of life. Well, it turns out that this eventuality is not likely. because there is not enough resonance. In this case, the numbers do not work well. The number for beryllium and helium together is 7.1616 MeV (the new carbon nucleus after the conjunction) while oxygen's number falls short with only 7.1187 MeV. That comes out to a difference of 0.0429 MeV, enough to prevent an easy merger between them.
And that's were all the carbon comes from. But where did we get all that oxygen? Current conjectures are that the oxygen that surrounds our planet now was released by the early life forms that lived by photosynthesis, the process by which the organism takes in CO2 and releases O2, one of the significant differences between plants and animals. Only then could land animals climb out of the water and flourish on the earth's surface. Since this chemical process is something that is known to be happening in the sun and other stars, we can accept it as real, even if we do not want to apply it to a naturalistic understanding of the Big Bang. In fact, I am fascinated by the order in Genesis 1. On the third day God created plant; on the fourth day he ordered the heavenly bodies, and then, on the fifth day did he create oxygen-breathing animals.
The point of this exposition should be clear enough. The path from the Big Bang to homo sapiens appears to be graced by a lot of extremely precise and narrow gates.