
Horses and Horseshoes
"Well, it's time to finish my thoughts that were sparked by reading Who Was Adam by Rana and Ross," was the first sentence in the original blog post. With this resurrected and somewhat revised site, we're not even half-way yet.
I left off by saying that there was a missing element in my description of the process of evolution up to that point. Let me review and clarify some of the previous points. I said that in order for evolution to happen, certain requirements must be met.
1. A change in the environment dramatic enough to require drastic adaptation of the organism to the environment. Insofar as evolution could happen, it is not something that an organism could will to come about. Even small adaptations within a species are forced on the animal or plant. Human beings have had a lot of success in breeding varieties of flowers and dogs, but they have done so by applying the ultimate force: "Change or get out of the genepool!" In many cases that has meant a quiet death for the specimens that were not found suitable.

It was Herbert Spencer, not Charles Darwin, who first came up with the phrase "survival of the fittest," a slogan that has been applied not only to plants and animals but also to the supposed superiority of one human ethnicity over another. If "survival of the fittest" is to mean anything, it must be purged of connotations of superiority, strength, even improvement. The American horse shoe crab, Limulus polyphemus, is considered to be one of the oldest animals since its appearance in the sea possibly to 445 million years ago. Its survival has certainly not been an example of Tennyson's "nature red in tooth and claw." It lives in a niche that is fairly safe and is protected by its shield. Unfortunately its continued existence is threatened by human beings invading their niche for their exploitation as a supposed gourmet treat. Not for me, I assure you.
Let me stress again the necessary condition of "sufficient magnitude." The Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium makes it clear that small disturbances in the gene pool are brought back into balance. Still, Stebbins has given us an example that we could test if only it gave us sufficient data and definitions. All genetic traits are located on our chromosomes, but we don't conclude that there are two species by examining the chromosomes directly or merely by the organism's outward appearance. The easiest test is whether they interbreed. The success of genome research has made it possible to recognize mutations in various alleles, but I don't think that we can or should be allowed to undertake a chromosome exam of a few thousand salamanders to keep track of all of their alleles. If they don't interbreed, we have two species. Due to the "reproductive isolation" of the two halves of the population of Ensatina in southern California that's exactly what could have happened. Of course, this is a rather murky situation because interbreeding takes place where there is a gap along the north-south line. Still, I can't get around the fact that, if the central population were eliminated, there would be no question that we were looking at a total of three species: one northern one and two southern ones. However, this is a hypothesis contrary to fact, though it seems to me that it could have illustrated a plausible mechanism for species identification if it had worked.
My second condition was: The emergence of mutations that will enable the organism to adapt to the new environment. The HW equilibrium demonstrates that the overall genotypes of a population remains in balance as long as there are no drastic forces. However, changes in individuals are common. Someone with an extraordinary skill in some field probably worked very hard to master it, perhaps as an athlete or musician. Nevertheless, if she had not come with the right genes occupying the right places on the right chromosomes, she would not have much to work on.
Let's be clear on this; species of organisms die out. Extinction may take place only locally, for instance in areas that had once teemed with wildlife until their specific environment became inhospitable. As mentioned before, some populations may become too small for their gene pool to maintain sufficient diversity to survive. Sometimes, extinction may be global. The departure of dinosaurs from this planet would be a good example. On the other hand, some birds (e.g., sparrows) find new niches to go on living, but their genotype does not change.

A "dendrogram" in evolutionary biology refers to the branches of the development of a contemporary species from its alleged original ancestor. In the accompanying dendrogram on horses, you may want to notice several points of development that are not necessarily evident in the diagram. The eohippus was roughly the size of a house cat and had the usual number of toes on each foot. Then there is the size of the legs in proportion to the torso. I can't say how precise the AI representation is, but if you look carefully, you may note that the legs get slightly larger in comparison to the bodies. What you probably cannot see is how much the hind legs have become extended. What may look like the calf is actually the foot, and what looks like the knee is the ankle.In addition, the five toes eventually turned into one hard hoof. These adaptations are thought to be intended to improve the horse's speed.
Second, the eohippus and the earliest forms were browsers (leaf eaters), who were replaced by horses with successive differences in their dentition in order to become grazers (grass eaters). But note that there is no direct connection between Mesohippus, the browser, and Merychippus, the grazer. The evolution of grazing horses coincides with the arrival of grass. Some animals, particularly some of the even-toed ones (artiodactyls), e.g., deer or moose, remained browsers, while some of the odd-toed ones (perissodactyls) became grazers, but that's not a hard-and-fast rule.
Clearly there is a world of difference between the peppered moth in its temporary appearance in a dark form and the evolution of large mammals. Our conclusion for the moths was that the gene pool never was affected; all the right genes for its lighter forms were still there when it became risky again to be dark. As the soot had settled over the industrial regions of northern England, the moths did not have to wait for one of them to start mutating into a suitably melanic form, but melanism was already in its genetic arsenal, as were the genes for the non-melanic phenotype. Given the significant difference between modern horses and the eohippus, there's no question that the genotype changed, and we know that in the absence of grazing on green grass, horses even now may eat some leaves, but they do not immediately flip back to becoming full-blown browsers.
But if you accept that the line from eohippus to Roy Rogers' Trigger involved a transition from leaves to grass, a fairly sizable question rears its head. How did it come about? Please keep in mind that the change from browser to grazer is considered an evolutionary one with the aforementioned changes in anatomy, not just a change in food preference. The answer is that grass emerged later than the evolving horse, but there's a whole lot more to the story, and I can't possibly go into too many details, but I'll come back to it after a few excursions.

When I was in school, the extinction of dinosaurs was a deep mystery, exacerbated by a multitude of theories, none of which were able to explain the extinction of apparently 75% of the animals all over the earth, including all non-flying dinosaurs. Nowadays you will be taught that it was the impact of a gigantic asteroid that caused a global catastrophe by extreme climate change 66 million years ago.
Even before the asteroid theory became popular, any discussion on the topic included the sentiment that what was tragic for the large reptilians was the the opportunity for small mammals to survive and increase in population numbers and in the size of their bodies. Not all dinosaurs disappeared at once; the flying ones are said to have evolved into birds.
The newly emerging mammals moved into different directions. The ones we care about in this section were the herbivorous browsers. However, there were also small carnivores that threatened their small vegetarian relatives. Avoiding martial metaphors, the story goes on with some carnivores and herbivores growing in size and the ability to create and avoid danger. Given the long time for these events to take place, one would assume that there was a certain amount of balance in compliance with the Hardy-Weinberg principle. The ancestors of horse and deer became able to reach leaves at increasing heights as well as becoming more agile and faster.
And then came the grass, but this was a double-sided blade. Abundant grass provided a whole new source of nutrition, but it also magnified the danger the carnivores may have caused. Now the story get blurred again. We said earlier that if evolution occurs, the prerequisites include persistent pressure and an isolated population that will undergo the needed transformation. Furthermore, there must be the capacity to change within the genotypes of the animals whose mutations spread incrementally throughout the population over and over again. We'll talk about this issue in the next installment.